Security best practices for API authentication?

We're designing a new API gateway and need recommendations for secure authentication methods. Should we use JWT, OAuth2, or API keys? How do we balance security with developer experience?

Find more posts tagged with

Accepted answers

All comments

Karen A. Thomas

From my experience securing APIs across multiple financial institutions, I've found that a hybrid approach using OAuth 2.0 with JWT tokens provides the best balance of security and usability. Here's why this combination works so well.

OAuth 2.0 handles the complex authorization flows beautifully, especially when you need to manage different client types (mobile apps, SPAs, server-side applications). JWTs, when used as access tokens, provide a stateless way to carry authorization data while remaining verifiable. The key is implementing them correctly.

One often-overlooked aspect is token lifecycle management. We implement short-lived access tokens (15-30 minutes) paired with longer-lived refresh tokens that rotate with each use. This approach minimizes the impact of token theft while maintaining a smooth user experience. We also maintain a token blacklist in Redis for immediate revocation capabilities - a crucial feature for enterprise clients.

Victorine Courtois

Let me share a practical approach to API security that has worked well for us across different client needs. Instead of choosing between authentication methods, we implemented a tiered system that offers different options based on the client's requirements and technical capabilities.

For service-to-service communication, we use API keys with additional security measures like IP whitelisting and rate limiting. For user-context operations, we leverage OAuth 2.0 with JWT tokens. This flexibility has been crucial in supporting both sophisticated enterprise clients and smaller developers who need a simpler integration path.

The real game-changer was implementing proper monitoring and analytics. We track authentication patterns, failure rates, and usage metrics for each authentication method. This data has been invaluable for identifying potential security issues and improving our developer experience.

Vanilla Forums

1. Essential Security Controls:
- TLS 1.3 enforcement
- Certificate pinning
- Strict CORS policies
- Input validation at all layers

2. Access Control Implementation:
- Role-based access control (RBAC)
- Resource-level permissions
- IP whitelisting options
- Rate limiting per client

3. Operational Security:
- Regular penetration testing
- Automated vulnerability scanning
- Incident response procedures
- Compliance monitoring

Remember: security is only as strong as its weakest link.